We are going to be immersed in it either way. Escaping popular culture since the advent of mass media, and especially now in the internet age, is practically impossible.
So lets be smart about it.
Steven Johnson said that everything bad is good for us. While this can be true of certain forms some parts of pop culture take, some bad things are just bad for us. Stereotypes, advertising, violence, cyber-bullies and rape culture; this is what gets brought along with the interactivity and expanded socialization. They aren't always obvious either. In fact, they are often sneaking and insidiously hiding in our shows and games and magazines.
This is the information age, so lets gain information about pop culture, our culture, so we can think critically, take stock of what is harmful to us or others, and make up our own minds.
In class we basically learned there is a feedback loop of pop culture reflecting us, and we trying to imitate it, until things have become distilled or exaggerated, and now by recognizing it we can exit it. We form our personalities to reality TV standards, which were only trying to figure out what people were like, and what viewers would like. We strive for the beauty presented in the media, until the beauty in the media isn't really what people wanted in the first place.
If we know how to take a step out of the cycle, and look around, we can begin to reject it, or hopefully change it for the better. Then we'll be able to make the most of the amazing connectedness that our current culture brings, and make the best use of the tools of the modern age.
Studying pop culture lets us step out of the mirror facing the mirror.
Sunday, December 9, 2012
Monday, December 3, 2012
Substance VS Fluff
The news broadcast we watched in class included some coverage of important stories, such as the fiscal cliff and its effect on medicare. Sadly I didn't think this was a very comprehensive report. Perhaps there would have been more time to cover an issue that will effect many American's in real and lasting ways, as opposed to spending so much time on a lottery drawing that hadn't even happened yet.
The Powerball piece was pointless, as was the piece about the as of yet unannounced NASA findings. That was clear ratings-bait. NASA has not said what their discovery is, and wild speculation about alien life is at best pointless, and at worst giving people unrealistic expectations of scientific discovery.
I think Chuck Klosterman would certainly find those two pieces meaningless, but I also think he would consider piece on Susan Rice to fall under this heading too. They didn't really report anything new or educate us about the situation, basically turning it into gossip.
The Powerball piece was pointless, as was the piece about the as of yet unannounced NASA findings. That was clear ratings-bait. NASA has not said what their discovery is, and wild speculation about alien life is at best pointless, and at worst giving people unrealistic expectations of scientific discovery.
I think Chuck Klosterman would certainly find those two pieces meaningless, but I also think he would consider piece on Susan Rice to fall under this heading too. They didn't really report anything new or educate us about the situation, basically turning it into gossip.
Monday, November 12, 2012
Real World vs. Reality
The difference between The Real World and reality lies in the depth and complexity of any given person, and the effort for an easily edited and easily consumed narrative culls away much of that complexity. Participants on The Real World, no matter who they are in reality, end up being portrayed as simplified archetypes. It's these archetypes that Chuck Klosterman saw people start to imitate and strive for. It makes a lazy, vapid person's life easier if they are easily understood by other lazy, vapid people, Chuck claims, and these archetypes are the perfect patterns for these people to fit themselves into. This leads to people needing something to make their lives interesting, and since actual hobbies or thoughts don't fit into an archetype, unless that thing defines you, then needless drama is all there is left. In Chuck's article this is exemplified by the two girls he heard planning to 'confront' their third roommate.
I see this exact type of whittling down from fictional media as well. It seems that since Sex and the City, most women over a certain age are trying to classify themselves and their friends a Carrie, Charlotte, Miranda, or Samantha. But I feel like their motivating force isn't to be simplified, but they hope that if they emulate those women, (and look, there's one for each of us), then they can achieve the same lifestyle those women have. Who doesn't want to be a cosmopolitan woman having humorous and exciting sexual dalliances and share those exploits over brunch?
But this flippant emulation isn't the only effect media can have. In making characters simplified (so they can be understood by the greatest number of people, and therefore, the greatest number of advertising demographics) many fictional characters on TV have devolved into stereotypes. These stereotypes are internalized by the people they relate to. This causes very negative and tangible results on people as we saw in the video in class a couple weeks back.
And in case anyone is curious, you TOO can know which Real World cast member you are most like: Real World Personality Quiz
Or perhaps you're wondering if you're a Samantha, Carrie, Miranda, or a Charlotte? Which Sex and the City character are you?
I see this exact type of whittling down from fictional media as well. It seems that since Sex and the City, most women over a certain age are trying to classify themselves and their friends a Carrie, Charlotte, Miranda, or Samantha. But I feel like their motivating force isn't to be simplified, but they hope that if they emulate those women, (and look, there's one for each of us), then they can achieve the same lifestyle those women have. Who doesn't want to be a cosmopolitan woman having humorous and exciting sexual dalliances and share those exploits over brunch?
But this flippant emulation isn't the only effect media can have. In making characters simplified (so they can be understood by the greatest number of people, and therefore, the greatest number of advertising demographics) many fictional characters on TV have devolved into stereotypes. These stereotypes are internalized by the people they relate to. This causes very negative and tangible results on people as we saw in the video in class a couple weeks back.
And in case anyone is curious, you TOO can know which Real World cast member you are most like: Real World Personality Quiz
Or perhaps you're wondering if you're a Samantha, Carrie, Miranda, or a Charlotte? Which Sex and the City character are you?
Monday, November 5, 2012
Not so different after all... Rap and Country
Chuck Klosterman made pointed out the common line that I've heard many a time, and not only from hipsters: "I like almost any music, except country."
Except that I usually hear this version: "I like almost any music, except rap and country."
While the popularity of both rap and country would demonstrate that they are actually pretty mainstream (I have to disagree with the idea that the number of radio stations dedicated to exclusively country and cd sales are a good indication to country music's popularity. Those stats only tell me that the people who listen to country are the people who still actually listen to the radio and buy albums), they are at the same time somehow niche genres.
In my totally unscientific experience, there are more rap music consumers who listen to exclusively rap and hip-hop, and country music consumers who listen exclusively to country, than consumers of either that listen to varied genres.
Beyond their strange places in society's music food-chain, rap and country share the problem with image. Artists in both genres have to worry about their cred. In both hip-hop and country the artist has to be from a certain socio-economic class, even if they've now risen above it, which they can also brag about. On one side you need street cred, on the other, farm cred. On one side you need to keep it real, and on the other you need to, in the Dixie Chicks case, fit the model of real Texans.
When they stepped out of the country 'party-line', there was an enormous backlash, to the point of death threats (considering how in a couple years, many Americans were easily saying how ashamed we were of our president, that was absurd).
Both of these genres must also work with snobbery. They are often pushed aside as not 'real music' or music for stupid, or trashy people. Which paired with the pride that the cultures surrounding both genres have of their class and circumstances, this is actually troubling.
Except that I usually hear this version: "I like almost any music, except rap and country."
While the popularity of both rap and country would demonstrate that they are actually pretty mainstream (I have to disagree with the idea that the number of radio stations dedicated to exclusively country and cd sales are a good indication to country music's popularity. Those stats only tell me that the people who listen to country are the people who still actually listen to the radio and buy albums), they are at the same time somehow niche genres.
In my totally unscientific experience, there are more rap music consumers who listen to exclusively rap and hip-hop, and country music consumers who listen exclusively to country, than consumers of either that listen to varied genres.
Beyond their strange places in society's music food-chain, rap and country share the problem with image. Artists in both genres have to worry about their cred. In both hip-hop and country the artist has to be from a certain socio-economic class, even if they've now risen above it, which they can also brag about. On one side you need street cred, on the other, farm cred. On one side you need to keep it real, and on the other you need to, in the Dixie Chicks case, fit the model of real Texans.
When they stepped out of the country 'party-line', there was an enormous backlash, to the point of death threats (considering how in a couple years, many Americans were easily saying how ashamed we were of our president, that was absurd).
Both of these genres must also work with snobbery. They are often pushed aside as not 'real music' or music for stupid, or trashy people. Which paired with the pride that the cultures surrounding both genres have of their class and circumstances, this is actually troubling.
Monday, October 29, 2012
Living in a Digital World
The documentary Digital Nation illustrated many troubling and interesting ways our world is different now that the internet has proliferated most parts our everyday lives.
It has changed the way we teach children, and how students like me expect to learn and experience school. It isn't strange that children should be taught how to use computers, considering that it is pretty hard to get by in the modern world without a basic understanding of how to use computers and the internet. But the implementation of personal computers for students can be a distraction, giving students a power they are not ready to handle, and creating even more competition for teachers. Children aren't known for their focus, and teachers have a hard enough time without putting innumerable websites at young student's fingertips. College professors claim that only 6% of students come well prepared.
This technological saturation causes even the smartest of students, as the film showed with the MIT students, to be distracted. Granted, the MIT students are tricked like many of us are, into feeling productive by doing several things 'at once'. We really think we are multi-tasking, except that studies show that we do worse at all tasks when we 'multi-task' than when we do those tasks alone. These are negatives without even getting into the idea of internet addiction.
But it's not all negative, when it comes to education. Games can teach children and keep them captivated in ways that antiquated teaching methods can't. If we deprived children of the technology they use at home in school, we miss out on a very good opportunity to teach children responsible use of technology. There are a numerous ways students can now use computers for academics.
School is changing though because the adult world of work and socialization has changed. As the documentary showed, IBM has moved most of their workers to a digital workplace Second Life. No more commuting or flying to business meetings. Online gaming similarly gives people a virtual realm to make friends, to go on adventures daily, and meet people they actually have things in common with instead of the people who happen to live nearby.
But virtual worlds don't only have these positive uses. The army uses military themed games and computer simulations to recruit, and to some this is trivializing the real costs of war and the real challenge of being in the military. Although, war in the the modern day isn't unlike gaming with the use of remotely controlled drones dropping bombs and surveilling.
The moral, it seemed, of Digital Nation, was that for every positive to the way society is being changed by technology, there is a negative. Which isn't that really the status quo? All progress in civilization comes with positive and negative consequences, we simply have to make the best of it.
Monday, October 1, 2012
Foot Ball High: Perfect examples of sports metaphors
![]() |
| Even with a helmet your brain still bounces around in your skull, guys. |
Therefore the most obvious sports metaphor from From "Knock out punch" to "Home Run" that I saw being taught and used by the players and coaches in the documentary was "You gotta play hurt." Those students were being taught that if the game is on the line, then perhaps your injury isn't all that bad. Several students at the end of the film excused this by saying they were young and that injuries heal, even though it is clear that real brain damage is caused by the very violent playing style that has been emphasized with these teams.
Second metaphor I saw in the documentary was "Be bold, never too cautious". Instead of a smart tactical game, the students are being encouraged more and more to play a physical game. To hit, hit, hit. The more violent the better.
Last of all is "Don't give up: fight on to victory." When the team that the documentary focused on, Shiloh, was playing against the number one high school team in america, Trinity, and they were being absolutely pummeled the coach told them to never cower down. That even though it was obvious to any observer they weren't going to win, they couldn't bow out, they had to play even harder. They couldn't give up, or let the other team take the victory easily so they could save their bodies from injury so maybe they could train harder and live to fight another day. No, that wasn't even an option.
Monday, September 24, 2012
Love + The Movies
I am in particular agreement with Chuck Klosterman on two points from This is Emo: that in movies and TV (and in most other forms of story telling) love is portrayed as, in his words, "mind-blowing, transcendent", devoid of everyday normalcy, and that we think because of what is portrayed in these stories that we won't be satisfied without this sort of love.
My first example is the movie Sweet Home Alabama. I don't have any extra regard for this movie over others, but it shows someone choosing between a very nice, perfectly fine guy, and the "mind-blowing, transcendent" guy. So transcendent was their love that it was represented by improbable meteorological phenomena (lightning literally struck something twice in that movie). If she'd chosen the perfectly fine guy, she probably would be happier in the long run, considering what we know about synthetic and natural happiness. But according to the movie she was unsatisfied with Patrick Dempsey.
I have an example which I think illustrates a movie where love isn't magical or the most important thing in life. Where a couple has problems but still ends on an (un-transcendent) hopeful note: The Devil Wears Prada. In that movie Anna Hathaway's character has a boyfriend, who she ends up fighting with, breaking up with, sleeping with a different jerk, and ends up quietly reconciling with her boyfriend. She ends up in a place where you assume she'll be pretty happy eventually, with no minds blown at all.
I think something else to wonder about is our relationship with stories and the media in this age. There were stories of dramatic romance from the Greeks, to Shakespeare, to Arthurian legend. Yet why is it now that we let these stories be more than entertainment, ways of passing on culture and wisdom, and become total models for our lives? Really, I want to know.
My first example is the movie Sweet Home Alabama. I don't have any extra regard for this movie over others, but it shows someone choosing between a very nice, perfectly fine guy, and the "mind-blowing, transcendent" guy. So transcendent was their love that it was represented by improbable meteorological phenomena (lightning literally struck something twice in that movie). If she'd chosen the perfectly fine guy, she probably would be happier in the long run, considering what we know about synthetic and natural happiness. But according to the movie she was unsatisfied with Patrick Dempsey.
I have an example which I think illustrates a movie where love isn't magical or the most important thing in life. Where a couple has problems but still ends on an (un-transcendent) hopeful note: The Devil Wears Prada. In that movie Anna Hathaway's character has a boyfriend, who she ends up fighting with, breaking up with, sleeping with a different jerk, and ends up quietly reconciling with her boyfriend. She ends up in a place where you assume she'll be pretty happy eventually, with no minds blown at all.
I think something else to wonder about is our relationship with stories and the media in this age. There were stories of dramatic romance from the Greeks, to Shakespeare, to Arthurian legend. Yet why is it now that we let these stories be more than entertainment, ways of passing on culture and wisdom, and become total models for our lives? Really, I want to know.
Monday, September 17, 2012
Portrayals of Women in Advertising
In "Killing Us Softly 3" Jean Kilbourne discusses a myriad of problems with how women are portrayed in advertising. Women are turned into sex objects, or even literal furniture. Women are dehumanized as violence against them is glorified and they are reduced to body parts. Girls are being shown as sex objects younger and younger. Women are silenced, the saying 'best seen and not heard' reinforced by their mouths or faces being obscured; they are just bodies.
Violence:
Violence against women portrayed as sexy. This woman is laying across a car, prone, a man standing over her looking over the car smugly like she was an animal he just killed.
Sexualizing of Children:
While this isn't technically an ad, but part of a photo spread from a fashion magazine in France, it is a perfect example of how a very young girl is posed as a woman. And not just a woman, a sultry woman (what other kind is there in ads?), with hip sticking out, shirt off the shoulder, and attempt at a 'sexy' gaze.
Woman as a literal object:
This one is pretty straight forward. This woman is literally a display table for these items being sold. Do these items make you look good when you wear them? Doesn't matter. Hot ladies are for selling anything, as Jean Kilbourne taught us.
Silenced:
This woman's face is obscured from view. Who she is, or that she is a person isn't important. She is a sexy body for wearing cloths. If she even enjoys wearing this swimsuit I have no idea from this ad.
Monday, September 10, 2012
Sexuality + Culture
The problem with sexuality in our current cultural climate is that we hold on to a lot of reservations about sexuality, so that while we are very sexually explicit, we aren't very sex-positive. We don't keep sex hush-hush the way we did while Marilyn Monroe was alive, we talk about it and pay a lot of attention to it, but then disparage women like Pamela Anderson. She's famous for being sexy, but it's that aspect of her that we consider trashy or cheap at the same time.
Pornography and its prevalence and wide range of genres can be considered a good thing, since it provides a space in culture for people to explore their sexual proclivities without feeling ashamed. If they are making a porn with it, then other people must like it. But the porn industry has a lot of negative facets as well. Mainstream porn contains a limited range of female body types and very unrealistic one sided sex.
Pornography and its prevalence and wide range of genres can be considered a good thing, since it provides a space in culture for people to explore their sexual proclivities without feeling ashamed. If they are making a porn with it, then other people must like it. But the porn industry has a lot of negative facets as well. Mainstream porn contains a limited range of female body types and very unrealistic one sided sex.
Monday, September 3, 2012
Consumption + Happiness
![]() |
| Finally, a class where a Mad Men reference is appropriate! |
Happiness
and popular culture are tied by one specific thread to me, and that is
consumerism. Whether it is consuming media (movies, books, music) or consuming products, we are usually consuming these
things with the ultimate goal of happiness. And advertising, a huge part of American popular culture, knows this.
Advertising can chip away at us until we, if only subconsciously, believe that there are things we can own that will help us attain the lifestyle we aspire to, the one that will make us happy. Don Draper said it on Mad Men, “Advertising is based on one thing, happiness.” If an ad can wiggle it's way into your mind, even just barely, to convince you that, as Gilbert said in the article, “The average person says, 'I know I will be happier with a Porsche than with a Chevy.'”
Advertising can chip away at us until we, if only subconsciously, believe that there are things we can own that will help us attain the lifestyle we aspire to, the one that will make us happy. Don Draper said it on Mad Men, “Advertising is based on one thing, happiness.” If an ad can wiggle it's way into your mind, even just barely, to convince you that, as Gilbert said in the article, “The average person says, 'I know I will be happier with a Porsche than with a Chevy.'”
What advertisements leave out of course is that if the Chevy gets you to work on time, doesn't break down a lot, and the payments aren't out of your budget, then you won't be any happier with the Porsche. Lets consider someone who can just barely afford their dream car. The car they have is OK, and it hasn't had any major malfunctions, (i.e. they are achieving their needs and aren't suffering the stress of constant automotive troubles) but they decide to go for the dream car. They now have acquired a quick rush of pleasure and the stress of barely being able to afford the car payments. Ads don't tell you that a seat warmer is nice, but you're quality of life isn't going to have a measurable gain from one (in fact the goal of advertising IS EXACTLY the opposite). Our culture tells us this is what we should strive for, getting the car we want, even though our brains are wired to make sure we're just fine with the Chevy.
While media is a product, and the lines between content and advertising blur more and more as time goes on, I see the consumption of media as having a more lasting impact on our happiness than the consumption of other material products. A good song effects your brain chemistry. It can really make you happy, and can release the stress that damages your health. And a thrilling story can create stress that distracts you from your troubles, or stimulates your brain. Also media, especially media that has fewer middlemen between consumer and creator, is a connection between people. People trying to express stories and feelings and themselves. And relationships between people create the most lasting happiness. It says so in The Futile Pursuit of Happiness, although it is only relegated to a parenthetical side-note: “Social interaction and friendships have been shown to give lasting pleasure.”
All in all, consumption ties popular culture to our personal pursuits of happiness, and not all consumption of popular culture is not primarily negative. Although it doesn't only have a negative effect on our happiness, there is some consumption that is better than others.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








