Monday, October 29, 2012

Living in a Digital World

The documentary Digital Nation illustrated many troubling and interesting ways our world is different now that the internet has proliferated most parts our everyday lives.  

It has changed the way we teach children, and how students like me expect to learn and experience school. It isn't strange that children should be taught how to use computers, considering that it is pretty hard to get by in the modern world without a basic understanding of how to use computers and the internet. But the implementation of personal computers for students can be a distraction, giving students a power they are not ready to handle, and creating even more competition for teachers. Children aren't known for their focus, and teachers have a hard enough time without putting innumerable websites at young student's fingertips. College professors claim that only 6% of students come well prepared. 

This technological saturation causes even the smartest of students, as the film showed with the MIT students, to be distracted. Granted, the MIT students are tricked like many of us are, into feeling productive by doing several things 'at once'. We really think we are multi-tasking, except that studies show that we do worse at all tasks when we 'multi-task' than when we do those tasks alone. These are negatives without even getting into the idea of internet addiction. 
But it's not all negative, when it comes to education. Games can teach children and keep them captivated in ways that antiquated teaching methods can't. If we deprived children of the technology they use at home in school, we miss out on a very good opportunity to teach children responsible use of technology. There are a numerous ways students can now use computers for academics. 
School is changing though because the adult world of work and socialization has changed. As the documentary showed, IBM has moved most of their workers to a digital workplace Second Life. No more commuting or flying to business meetings. Online gaming similarly gives people a virtual realm to make friends, to go on adventures daily, and meet people they actually have things in common with instead of the people who happen to live nearby. 

But virtual worlds don't only have these positive uses. The army uses military themed games and computer simulations to recruit, and to some this is trivializing the real costs of war and the real challenge of being in the military. Although, war in the the modern day isn't unlike gaming with the use of remotely controlled drones dropping bombs and surveilling. 
The moral, it seemed, of Digital Nation, was that for every positive to the way society is being changed by technology, there is a negative. Which isn't that really the status quo? All progress in civilization comes with positive and negative consequences, we simply have to make the best of it. 

Monday, October 1, 2012

Foot Ball High: Perfect examples of sports metaphors

Even with a helmet your brain still bounces around in your skull, guys.
In the documentary Football High the major moral of the story seemed to be the violence and actual long-term, even fatal, injury that high school football can cause. 
Therefore the most obvious sports metaphor from From "Knock out punch" to "Home Run"  that I saw being taught and used by the players and coaches in the documentary was "You gotta play hurt." Those students were being taught that if the game is on the line, then perhaps your injury isn't all that bad. Several students at the end of the film excused this by saying they were young and that injuries heal, even though it is clear that real brain damage is caused by the very violent playing style that has been emphasized with these teams. 
Second metaphor I saw in the documentary was "Be bold, never too cautious". Instead of a smart tactical game, the students are being encouraged more and more to play a physical game. To hit, hit, hit. The more violent the better.
Last of all is "Don't give up: fight on to victory." When the team that the documentary focused on, Shiloh, was playing against the number one high school team in america, Trinity, and they were being absolutely pummeled  the coach told them to never cower down. That even though it was obvious to any observer they weren't going to win, they couldn't bow out, they had to play even harder.  They couldn't give up, or let the other team take the victory easily so they could save their bodies from injury so maybe they could train harder and live to fight another day. No, that wasn't even an option.