Monday, September 24, 2012

Love + The Movies

I am in particular agreement with Chuck Klosterman on two points from This is Emo: that in movies and TV (and in most other forms of story telling) love is portrayed as, in his words, "mind-blowing, transcendent", devoid of everyday normalcy, and that we think because of what is portrayed in these stories that we won't be satisfied without this sort of love.
My first example is the movie Sweet Home Alabama. I don't have any extra regard for this movie over others, but it shows someone choosing between a very nice, perfectly fine guy, and the "mind-blowing, transcendent" guy. So transcendent was their love that it was represented by improbable meteorological phenomena (lightning literally struck something twice in that movie). If she'd chosen the perfectly fine guy, she probably would be happier in the long run, considering what we know about synthetic and natural happiness. But according to the movie she was unsatisfied with Patrick Dempsey.
I have an example which I think illustrates a movie where love isn't magical or the most important thing in life. Where a couple has problems but still ends on an (un-transcendent) hopeful note: The Devil Wears Prada. In that movie Anna Hathaway's character has a boyfriend, who she ends up fighting with, breaking up with, sleeping with a different jerk, and ends up quietly reconciling with her boyfriend.  She ends up in a place where you assume she'll be pretty happy eventually, with no minds blown at all.
I think something else to wonder about is our relationship with stories and the media in this age. There were stories of dramatic romance from the Greeks, to Shakespeare, to Arthurian legend. Yet why is it now that we let these stories be more than entertainment, ways of passing on culture and wisdom, and become total models for our lives? Really, I want to know.

1 comment:

  1. You ask a very good question at the end of your post. I agree that many people take the media's portrayal or romance much too literally. If people would just watch a movie as a movie and not try and base their life off of that movie then there would be many less unsatisfied people in the world.

    ReplyDelete