Monday, November 12, 2012

Real World vs. Reality

The difference between The Real World and reality lies in the depth and complexity of any given person, and the effort for an easily edited and easily consumed narrative culls away much of that complexity. Participants on The Real World, no matter who they are in reality, end up being portrayed as simplified archetypes. It's these archetypes that Chuck Klosterman saw people start to imitate and strive for. It makes a lazy, vapid person's life easier if they are easily understood by other lazy, vapid people, Chuck claims, and these archetypes are the perfect patterns for these people to fit themselves into. This leads to people needing something to make their lives interesting, and since actual hobbies or thoughts don't fit into an archetype, unless that thing defines you, then needless drama is all there is left. In Chuck's article this is exemplified by the two girls he heard planning to 'confront' their third roommate.
I see this exact type of whittling down from fictional media as well. It seems that since Sex and the City, most women over a certain age are trying to classify themselves and their friends a Carrie, Charlotte, Miranda, or Samantha. But I feel like their motivating force isn't to be simplified, but they hope that if they emulate those women, (and look, there's one for each of us), then they can achieve the same lifestyle those women have. Who doesn't want to be a cosmopolitan woman having humorous and exciting sexual dalliances and share those exploits over brunch?
But this flippant emulation isn't the only effect media can have. In making characters simplified (so they can be understood by the greatest number of people, and therefore, the greatest number of advertising demographics) many fictional characters on TV have devolved into stereotypes. These stereotypes are internalized by the people they relate to. This causes very negative and tangible results on people as we saw in the video in class a couple weeks back.

And in case anyone is curious, you TOO can know which Real World  cast member you are most like: Real World Personality Quiz
Or perhaps you're wondering if you're a Samantha, Carrie, Miranda, or a Charlotte? Which Sex and the City character are you?

3 comments:

  1. I agree with your article and I like seeing it from your perspective. These "archetypes" are real. We see them all the time on Reality TV shows and not just on The Real World. I think that they "set the standard" in people's eyes. They think that this is how they are supposed to act or supposed to think becasue that it was is seen on TV which means it is socially acceptable. I liked your comment on the needless drama and how we always need something in our life to make it "interesting." As if our lives were so boring that nothing else could entertain us, we need drama in it to mix it up and it to make it interesting. As entertaining as these shows may be, I think they send a negative social stimga out to people because that's who they think they need to be or live up to in order to be "cool" or socially accepted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I thought you did a tremendous job of explaining things through the perspective of Chuck. You hit on many of his key points as well as provided many different examples. I see the show Real World as a show of just fighting about nonsense. It is as if they have nothing better to do in their lives then to sit and argue back and forth about stupid stuff. Just because it's on television they have to try and stand up to be cool in a sense.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Along with the archetypes, It makes me wonder if the people being cast for the roles know ahead of time which one they are supposed to be. As long as the show has been on it is most definite to me that there is no more "Real World" in the show at all :)

    ReplyDelete